Candidate Scorecard Software

Make choosing who to hire faster, fairer, and more objective

Replace scattered notes and gut feelings with structured feedback your team can rely on. Scorecards keep interviews aligned, clarify comparisons, and help you move forward with confidence.

pinpoint ats ui example of candidate scorecards to help make hiring easier

Evaluate every candidate against what matters most

Scorecards align interviewers around a shared set of criteria, so candidates are assessed consistently. With scorecards, your team avoids over-weighting less relevant signals and makes more confident, high-quality hiring decisions.

Each interviewer submits their scorecard independently, to help keep responses unbiased and ensure every perspective is captured clearly. Pinpoint automatically reminds interviewers to complete their scorecards, so recruiters don’t have to chase feedback manually.

pinpoint ats ui example of candidate scorecards to help make hiring easier

All scorecards are brought together in one view, with overall scores, criteria breakdowns, and summaries of written feedback. Your team can compare candidates side by side and make decisions based on shared data.

pinpoint ats ui example of candidate scorecards to help make hiring easier

Not every criteria should carry the same importance. Weightings let you give more influence to the areas that matter most for the role. When a weighting is applied, that score has a greater impact on the candidate’s overall result. 

pinpoint ats ui example of candidate scorecards to help make hiring easier

Generate a quick summary of every scorecard on the candidate profile to see a concise overview of each interviewer’s feedback. It highlights key themes and sentiment, so you can understand the overall picture without reading every response in full. Scorecard data also feeds directly into AI Hiring Copilot, where you can get a clearer view of overall fit before making a decision.

pinpoint ats ui example of candidate scorecards to help make hiring easier

What Pinpoint's candidate scorecard software includes

Configurable metric scoring
Short/long/yes-no questions
Optional interview guidance text
Independent reviewer submissions
Optional submission lock
Scorecard ratings dashboard
Per-reviewer score breakdown
AI sentiment + summaries
XLS export options
Reusable company templates
Multi-scorecards per stage
Bias-reduction toolkit part 
Chosen by leading talent acquisition and HR teams
Hospitality

65%

reduction in time to hire

Streamlined

casting day coordination

Increased

candidate communication

“With these new tools, we’ve set a good foundation to scale our hiring while maintaining our culture and delivering a really great candidate and employee experience.”
Michael Easton
Head of Employee Value Proposition, citizenM
Nonprofit

Strengthened

candidate engagement

Increased

candidate trust

Reduced

reliance on paid ads

“Pinpoint has completely changed how we work. We're more efficient, more consistent, and better equipped to give every candidate a great experience.”
Emma Bishop
Resourcing Manager, Blue Cross
Professional Services

Lower

risk of candidates stalling

Improved

visibility for TA leaders and stakeholders

3,500

employees supported in the states

“I just love that I can manage everything and every role in one place without having to jump between systems.”
Liz Mellor
Head of Talent Acquisition for North America, Davies Group
Retail

Centralized

visibility on all candidates

100+

locations supported

Strengthened

hiring manager adoption

“It’s been really lovely using Pinpoint to align things a bit more. Across the board now, all of our candidates are getting a more similar experience, and the communication they’re getting is much stronger.”
Adam Barnes
UK&I Retailer, Lush
Bring consistency to your interview process
Discover how scorecards help your team capture feedback, compare candidates, and make clearer decisions.
G2
4.8
Capterra
4.8
SSR
4.8

Candidate scorecard FAQs

Candidate scorecard software helps hiring teams evaluate candidates against agreed criteria. It gives interviewers a structured way to record feedback, compare candidates, and reduce inconsistent evaluation.

Scorecards help teams stay aligned on what they're assessing. They can improve consistency, make hiring feedback easier to compare, and reduce reliance on vague or unstructured interview notes.

Yes. Pinpoint's scorecards live inside the hiring process, so hiring managers and interviewers give structured feedback in the platform rather than over email or in spreadsheets. Because Pinpoint doesn't charge per hiring-manager seat, you can involve every interviewer without a per-user cost.

Scorecards draw on the criteria set at intake and sit alongside the candidate's full record, interview schedule, and communication history. That keeps evaluation consistent from kickoff to decision, and feeds reporting on how candidates are being assessed.

Candidate Scorecard FAQs

Waiting for FAQ from Pinpoint